A billionairess convicted of fraud protests her innocence in a bizarre, sometimes uncomfortable documentary which leaves too many questions unanswered.
House of guilt, maybe: Elizabeth Holmes, Billy Evans, baby and Nathan Fielder
Photo courtesy of A24.
by JAMES CAMERON-WILSON
The alternative comedian and filmmaker Nathan Fielder is invited into the home of Elizabeth Holmes to record her last 34 days before she goes to prison. He is given total access to her world, allowed to ask her the most probing (impertinent?) questions, film her breastfeeding and even to show her partner, Billy Evans, in the shower. Nothing appears off-limits. Initially, at least, the only note of dissent seems to be how Fielder’s film crew is interfering with the couple’s wi-fi. One suspects that Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans believe that Fielder’s documentary will show the world how innocent Elizabeth really is. It’s hard to imagine who would invite this man, known for his acerbic satire, into their living quarters, as his interview technique is more interrogation than conversational, where he punctuates his grilling with, “how do you mean?” or “like what?” He appears to want as clear an answer as possible and allows his innumerable pauses to goad his victims further, to say perhaps more than they would care to reveal.
One often wonders why any subject would allow themselves to be interviewed and what exactly is Elizabeth Holmes’ agenda. This feels more like Fielder’s show and only gradually does he allow his subject’s story to emerge. Even so, Fielder and his covert co-director Lance Oppenheim (who recently brought us Primetime) have landed a fascinating protagonist, and the film’s early scenes are nothing short of mesmerising. With her angelic features, constant half-smile and propensity to shed silent tears, Holmes is a picture of virtue who swears to Fielder that she has never knowingly told a lie, not even a white one.
There are other characters, too, saved for later on in the film’s self-indulgent running time (174 minutes), but it is Elizabeth Holmes who is the star, like a deer, as it were, caught in the headlights of Fielder’s cross-examination. Personally, I wanted to know much more about this seemingly altruistic entrepreneur, who we learn has invented a device that can assess a person’s health from a mere finger prick of blood, thus undermining all the good deeds of the medical establishment. This is not the first record of her life, either, as Amanda Seyfried played her in the Hulu miniseries The Dropout (2022), which Fielder forces Holmes to watch on his laptop until she cannot take any more.
It should be noted that his protagonist was the youngest and wealthiest self-made female billionaire in US history and was convicted of fraud for deceiving her investors and patients on an epic scale. Invited to stay at Holmes’ luxury beach-side residence in Del Mar, San Diego, Fielder divides his film into segments, using chapter headings to count down the days until her incarceration. He also introduces a new kind of interview technique, a sort of cruel empathy as he belittles Holmes for her use of wording and her inability to properly understand a sketch by Abbott & Costello. Then, just before her departure, before her eleven-year stretch in prison, he allows her two hours alone with Billy. Then, mid-film, he changes course and plays with the documentary form itself, providing a meta hybrid at the expense of his former hostess.
Fielder and Oppenheim make it both an uncomfortable and electric thing to watch, blending aspects of satire, conspiracy thriller, character study and reenactment, posing more questions than either can possibly answer. But what they do do for Holmes is to platform her utter self-belief in her innocence. “I know I didn’t commit any crime,” she tells Fielder. So, we may be able to see everything, but there is so much more that we want to know.
Featuring Nathan Fielder, Elizabeth Holmes, Billy Evans, Amanda Seyfried, Christopher Abbott.
Dir Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, Pro Nathan Fielder, Lance Oppenheim, Tatiana Bears, Maggie Ambrose and Jack Davis, Ph David Bolen, Pro Des Alex DiGerlando, Ed Adam Locke-Norton, Music Ari Balouzian, Costumes Katina Danabassis.
A24/To Be Formed/Blow Out Productions-A24 Films.
174 mins. USA. 2026. US Rel: 16 October 2026. UK Rel: 20 November 2026. Cert. 15.