The latest outstanding documentary about the situation in Gaza reveals the circumstances through the eyes of three physicians.
Image courtesy of Conic.
by MANSEL STIMPSON
Poh Si Teng’s film American Doctor is yet another work that joins the list of outstanding documentaries about the situation in Gaza. Recently when reviewing and acclaiming NAZA I stressed the fact that several pieces centred on this issue were of exceptional quality and had the virtue of each having a distinctive approach which rendered them all valuable. And so it is here since American Doctor looks at things through the eyes of three doctors who, although living in the USA, offered their services to hospitals in Gaza to make some contribution to alleviating the suffering of civilians. One of them Thaer Ahmad was frustrated in his efforts because, although born in Chicago, he is Palestinian-American and was consequently denied access to Gaza by the Israeli authorities. What he has been able to do is to speak out about Gaza in the USA publicly criticising the stance of the American government, seeking to influence politicians by visiting Washington to make representations and making good use of television and social media to express his views.
The other two doctors featured also live in America but have different backgrounds and have accordingly been successful in reaching Nasser hospital in the city of Khan Younis and it is there that we find them in March 2025 at the time of a temporary ceasefire. Mark Perlmutter is himself Jewish but also the most outspoken of the three not hesitating to describe Israel's actions in Gaza as genocide. He is an orthopaedic surgeon while the film's third man, Feroze Sidhwa, is a second-generation Pakistani-American who practises as a trauma surgeon. He is quieter than Perlmutter in his manner but no less critical (when interviewed on television on Israeli Channel 13 he challenges the claim that Hamas had tunnels under the hospital having seen no evidence of it).
In the course of American Doctor we get to know something about each of these doctors: we see Ayat Ahmd, Thaer’s wife, together with their children, meet Mark Perlmutter’s partner, Amy Morris, in North Carolina and hear from Feroze about his parents and his beliefs as a Zoroastrian. However, most of the American footage is concerned with the ways in which these three promote their concerns about America’s stance on Gaza (when in the USA Mark and Feroze are quite as committed to that as Thaer is). Late on in the film when Mark and Feroze have returned home both of them admit to feeling guilty about not staying on in Gaza. But the decision was a lucky one for them since they are back in America when they learn that the Nasser hospital has been attacked and bombed out of existence.
The scenes in America are always interesting and bring a degree of variety to the piece which is welcome. But, as one would expect, it is the footage shot in and around Nasser hospital which provides the core of the film. Here we also get to see some of the local doctors and men like the anaesthesiologist Abd Almuti Eid, all of whom are dedicated to their work there. But, while Poh Si Teng’s film honours them, its central concern is to reveal the state of things in the hospital. The view taken in American Doctor is that people have the right to know the truth and an early scene emphasises this by opting not to blur images of dead children permission to do that having been obtained.
For the most part responses to American Doctor have rightly been very positive. Considering that this is the first feature film to have been made by Poh Si Teng, her achievement is remarkable. The film undoubtedly holds one from beginning to end and my only reservation concerned a certain lack of clarity in its structure. At one point an undated statement comes up suddenly announcing that what follows took place two months earlier. After that it is not too easy to tell at what stage this flashback sequence comes to an end and to recognise how what we see later fits in place with the footage seen in the film’s first scenes. As it happens, both Mark and Feroze went out to Gaza on medical missions in 2024 and again in 2025.
It is also the case that the odd voice commenting on the film has declared that it should have taken a more balanced view of the situation and given due recognition to the sufferings inflicted on Israelis. To raise that point seems to me to show a basic misunderstanding of what American Doctor set out to do. Its three central figures from disparate backgrounds are united in being horrified by what has happened in Gaza. As Americans they share concern that the American Medical Association has not issued any formal condemnation of this despite the fact that targeting civilian hospitals amounts to a war crime. Being aware of conditions at Nasser hospital - Mark and Feroze relying on what they have actually seen on the spot and Thaer giving detailed attention to reports - they have all recognised just how extreme it has been. Despite being doctors and therefore used to dealing with the injured, the numbers of dead and wounded has indeed shocked them deeply. Having to treat so many women and children in such an appalling state is absolutely of the essence here (as when a woman patient is brought in and the question is not just if you can save her arm but whether she is also likely to lose one or both legs). Furthermore, Mark is officially on record as declaring that 90% of the patients he treated in Gaza emergency rooms were children.
Late on reference is made to other innocent victims when it is recorded that at the time filming was completed no less than 1700 healthcare workers had been killed in Gaza since October 2023. In making all this vivid to a worldwide audience American Doctor is not taking political sides and is not concerned with past history. Instead, its focus is on a particular set of actions that have played out in Gaza and which recognisably amount to genocide. No wider context than that comes into play and does not need to. The impact which events in Gaza have made on Mark, Feroze and Thaer has led to a film that stands as clear testimony to the fact that what we are shown here is irrefutable evidence of war crimes.
Featuring Thaer Ahmad, Mark Perlmutter, Feroze Sidhwa, Abd Almuti Eid, Khalid Al Serr, Ayham Abu Elqomboz, Sama Qudaih, Yousef Alsabe, Ayat Ahmad, Amy Morris, Baraa Abualroos.
Dir Poh Si Teng, Pro Poh Si Teng, Kirstine Barfod and Reem Haddad, Ph Ibrahim Al-Otla, Chris Renteria, Arthur Nazaryan, Poh Si Teng and Ramzy Haddad, Ed Christopher White and Ema Ryan Yamazaki, Music Suad Bushnaq.
Alef Multimedia/Elk Film/Tiny Boxer Films/Watermelon Pictures-Conic.
90 mins. USA/Malaysia/UK/Qatar/Denmark/Switzerland/Palestine. 2026. US Rel: 14 August 2026. UK Rel: 20 November 2026. Cert. 18.